Werewolves, Deer-Cows and Other Medieval Monsters

Werewolves, Deer-Cows and Other Medieval Monsters

Medieval bestiaries and chronicles preserve a genuinely bizarre menagerie of supposed cross-species creatures, and — fascinating from a historical point of view — the twelfth century marks a real, documented shift in how educated writers thought about the actual biological boundary between humans and animals.

Before this period, the two categories were considered entirely, unbridgeably separate; afterward, writers like Gerald of Wales began seriously entertaining the idea that genuine cross-breeding might actually be possible, which made existing fears about bestiality considerably more frightening — no longer just a private sin, but a potential source of literal monsters. Gerald reported, with a completely straight face, the birth of a “deer-cow” from a stag mating with a domestic cow near the Welsh border, and a litter of “monkey-dogs” born to a bitch that had supposedly mated with an ape — helpfully explaining that the evidence had been destroyed when a disgusted castle warden killed the whole litter with a stick before anyone official could properly examine them.

Werewolf stories followed a similar pattern, tangled up with genuine anxiety about dangerous women: Gerald describes a beautiful woman who “turned into a hairy creature, rough and shaggy” during sex, while Gervase of Tilbury claimed personal acquaintance with two actual werewolves, one of whom he says devoured infants (offering no further detail as to who these supposed werewolves actually were). Medieval bestiaries also warned pregnant women against looking at ugly animals like apes and monkeys, for fear the resulting child might resemble them — a genuine, widely held belief that a mother’s visual experience during conception could directly shape her unborn child’s appearance. None of it holds up under any modern biological scrutiny, obviously, but it offers a useful window into how seriously — and how anxiously — medieval scholars took the question of exactly where the boundary between human and animal actually sat.


Visit westerbone.com for more insights into medieval historical fiction.