Medieval Theories About Conception and Sex
Medieval theories about how babies were conceived reveal, in genuinely startling detail, just how thoroughly male-authored assumptions shaped every aspect of sex and reproduction — right down to determining a foetus’s sex.
The dominant theory held that a child formed when a man’s “seed” mixed with matter contributed by the mother — conception on the woman’s left side supposedly produced a girl, the right side a boy, and some writers even claimed a difference in breast size could predict which. A competing, equally unfounded theory suggested girls resulted from “defective” semen, which then made the resulting daughter long for sexual union with a “more perfect” male to compensate. Underlying much of this was the ancient belief that women’s reproductive organs were simply an inverted, defective version of a man’s — women as, in essence, incomplete males.
Perhaps the most consequential belief, though, was that conception could only occur if both partners experienced sexual pleasure during intercourse. For a woman made pregnant by rape, this created a devastating legal and social bind: pregnancy itself was taken as proof she must have been a willing, aroused participant, since the prevailing medical theory insisted conception was otherwise impossible. Male theorising, quite literally, overrode any woman’s actual account of what had happened to her. This belief in mutual arousal as a precondition for pregnancy sat alongside official Church teaching that marital sex existed for one purpose only — reproduction — and was formally banned during pregnancy, breastfeeding, menstruation, and on a long list of religious fast days throughout the year, leaving remarkably few days on the calendar when sex was both theologically permitted and, by the era’s own logic, actually likely to work.
Browse all historical mystery titles by M. J. Westerbone at westerbone.com/books.